ELA Weekly Journal Assignment Week 2-C.M


In Persepolis, Why Does Marjane Want To Make Her Past Dissapear (Page 194)?

    I think that Marjane wants to make her past disappear because she is feeling guilty. The main reason she is feeling this guilt is because she feels like a coward and a disgrace for smoking joints and behaving like a punk when her parents are getting bombed every day. One panel in page 193 supports my theory. Marjane, talking about her parents thinking of her as a dream child, says “If only they knew… If they knew that their daughter was made up like a punk, that she smoked joints to make a good impression, that she had seen men in their underwear while they were being bombed every day, they wouldn't call me their dream child.” More evidence can be found in pages 194-195, where Marjane is denying her nationality and not watching the news when they’re reporting on Iran. She says on page 195 that being from Iran was a heavy burden, since Iran was seen as an “evil” place. I think it’s understandable that Marjane feels guilty for being in Europe during her country's time of war, but I don’t understand why she feels like she has to hide her nationality from others. Even if Iran is seen as a country of evil, it’s important to be proud of where you came from.

Comments

  1. Sayer CharnquistSeptember 29, 2017 at 4:57 PM

    I can completely agree with this. I find it very smart how you point out that she is just relaxing instead of helping. Though to be fair she quite literally cannot help her family out.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Francesc045October 1, 2017 at 6:20 PM

    Do you think Marjane's lack of communication with God could have any influence on the way she is acting?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Cole BargerOctober 2, 2017 at 6:35 PM

    Your point about her not wanting to be known as being from Iran because it is considered an evil place is a very strong help to your argument. And I agree that you should always be proud of your country, maybe not the people, but at least your country. Nice work!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Blog #4: Reflect On OHP

C.M Dr. Cobos ELA 10.29.17 Now that you have completed an interview, what would you do differently next time you need to do an interview?     I actually wasn’t at my groups interview, I did make up for it by transcribing more of the interview and writing and editing body paragraphs for our final project. So even though I missed the actual interview, I interacted with it more than many. The thing that bugged me the most that I would certainly change in a future interview interview was the fact that we didn’t get all the names of family members that our interviewee talked about. This made it really hard to make body paragraphs for our final projects. In my next interview, I would definitely make sure I have names of all the people our interviewee talks about and I have permission to use those names.     Another thing I would change in a future interview, or in this case Oral History Project, is how we used the recordings of our interview. In this...
Read more

Blog #3: Persepolis

C.M Dr. Cobos ELA 10.27.17 In what ways did Marjane find it difficult to fit back into Iranian society?     One of the ways Marjane is finding it difficult to fit back into Iranian society is understanding why one in every street is named after a martyr. Marjane's father explains that the reason so many streets are named after martyrs is because the entire war between Iran and Iraq was just a setup to destroy both armies by the west, who sold weapons to both sides. While the parents of these martyrs are overjoyed that their kids are dead, Marjane can’t understand the absurdity of this situation (Page 253). Another way in which Marjane is seeing different from Iranian society is in terms of hope for the future. While many Iranians, including her own parents, are hopeful for the future and putting the terrors of war behind them, Marjane isn’t feeling motivated to move forward, and she thinks that her parents secretly aren't motivated as well (Page 257). In the ...
Read more